![]()
|
In studying the actions of individuals, we learn also everything about the collectives and society. For the collective has no existence and reality but in the actions of individuals. It comes into existence by ideas that move individuals to behave as members of a definite group and goes out of existence when the persuasive power of these ideas subsides. The only way to a cognition of collectives is the analysis of the conduct of its members. -- Ludwig von Mises, The Ultimate Foundation of Economic Science, 1962. By philosophy and temperament, I'm a methodological individualist. My interest in history has always concentrated itself on the lives and actions of individual people. Much of what I find myself reading, therefore, is either biography or history that focuses on the motivations and decisions of key men and women. I'm not particularly inspired -- and in fact am usually rather bored -- by the sweeping analysis of social history (better described once as "retrospective sociology"). The kinds of analysis I prefer is sometimes derided as the "kings and battles" school of historiography. But as the quote I used to have posted on my Amazon.com page notes, there's a difference between good history and simple storytelling: There are two types of military history. One is what we might call romantic military history. I was talking to the military historian Russell Weigley shortly before he died about a very well-known historian who had a lot of success writing books about the American fighting man. Weigley said he was sad to see a respected historian raising monuments rather than writing history. In the same breath, Weigley noted that a veteran told him that these books make us feel good about ourselves. There is nothing wrong with this romantic military history as long as we recognize its limitations. It is a celebration. But we must also ask the hard questions. -- Max Hastings, Books & Culture, March/April 2005 All that said, here are...
|
|
Ten Historical Figures
I Particularly Admire
|
This page last updated on
Saturday, March 22, 2008
E-mail: andrew (at) andrewrogers (dot) net